Tories call on Treasury to fund green energy plans

10.01.22

News

UK: Tories call on Treasury to fund green energy plans

BBC News

There is extensive continuing coverage across the UK media of the “cost of living” crisis, which is being exacerbated by the spiralling cost of energy. Many outlets focus on the divergent views within the governing Conservative party over how best to tackle the issue. BBC News reports that “a group of green-minded Tory MPs says the government should fund environmental and social energy policies from the Treasury, instead of from consumer bills”. It adds: “The Conservative Environment Network (CEN), which includes 116 MPs, says the temporary measure would ease the surge in household costs. But the group opposes a separate proposal to abolish the 5% VAT on energy bills, saying it would effectively provide a subsidy for fossil fuels. The CEN is urging ministers to reduce bills and emissions in the long term by ensuring the UK’s homes are better insulated. The plea is endorsed by the Energy Efficiency Infrastructure Group – an alliance of businesses and charities who will write to the prime minister on Monday [reported today by a separate BBC News article], arguing better insulation for people in sub-standard housing could cut bills by £500 a year. But the current crisis over energy bills has revealed divisions among Conservative backbenchers. The plan to scrap VAT on energy has been pushed by the Net Zero Scrutiny Group of Tory MPs and peers. The caucus, with around 20 followers, has been linked to the anti-green pressure group formerly known as the Global Warming Policy Forum, which was founded by the former chancellor Nigel Lawson. Although its numbers are small, it is well connected in Conservative media.” (See DeSmog‘s analysis of how the media coverage of “Tory MPs’ energy bills letter ignores ties to climate science denial group”.)

Several right-leaning newspapers prominently report the concerns of “senior Tories”. For example, the Mail on Sunday leads with an interview with Lord Frost, the recently resigned former Brexit minister, who warns Boris Johnson, the prime minister, “be a true Tory Boris or you’re out”. He is quoted as saying: “I think people have been sold a kind of view that the net-zero transition can happen without much increase in costs or problems. That’s obviously not the case and people are now seeing that. I personally think that climate change is serious. But I’m not convinced it’s the most serious problem that we face. The country faces lots of other problems and we need to do everything we can to keep the cost of energy low and focus on security of supply. Green politics, net-zero, the climate emergency are part of mainstream opinion but it’s really important to keep debating, keep hearing alternative perspectives on this if we’re going to reach the right policies. And that’s what Conservatism means.” Similarly , the frontpage of today’s Daily Mail says that “three select committee chairmen last night told the Daily Mail that failure to take decisive action [over the cost of living] could see support for the Conservatives collapse”. It quotes Julian Knight, chairman of the Commons culture committee, saying: ‘In the short-term, [Johnson] needs to abolish the VAT on energy bills and get rid of the green taxes.“ [Knight is one of the members of the “net zero scrutiny group” of 19 MPs.]

The Sun says that “Johnson is cruising for a Red Wall bruising because of his dithering on the rising cost of living and soaring energy bills, new polling shows”. The Times reports: “A third of voters expect their energy bills to become unaffordable this year, increasing the pressure on Boris Johnson to protect against the rising cost of living. Most people want taxpayer money used to offset rises in gas and electricity bills but the government is being urged by Labour to scrap VAT on fuel.”

Several outlets cover the opposition Labour party’s proposal for how best to tackle the crisis. BBC News says: “Labour has called for a windfall tax on North Sea gas and oil producers to help limit the expected rise in household gas and electricity bills by £200. The party says its £6.6bn plan would also remove VAT on domestic energy costs for a year and increase the warm homes discount for poorer households.” The Sun says Labour has unveiled a “radical blueprint to tackle the energy crisis and cut household bills by up to £600 a year”. The Conservative-supporting newspaper adds: “The relief package would be…backed by long-term action to end reliance on imported gas by speeding up delivery of renewables and nuclear generators. Labour’s response will steal a march on the Tories who are divided over how to help families survive the soaring cost of living.” The Guardian notes the views of Ed Miliband, Labour’s shadow secretary for climate change and net-zero, who says that it “beggars belief” that the government is opposing a windfall tax on oil and gas companies. The Daily Telegraph covers the reaction of the the sector’s trade association, Oil and Gas UK. It says that “opportunistic” calls to launch a “further raid on an already heavily taxed sector is counterproductive”, adding that it would “hit energy security and green investment”. (See the Comment section below for reaction to the energy-price crisis.)

Separately, in other UK news, the Independent reports that “oil and gas companies have been invited by the government to help write the rules on whether new drilling complies with the UK’s climate obligations, just months after Boris Johnson urged countries to stop extracting fossil fuels at COP26”. And the Daily Telegraph carries a frontpage story headlined: “Green payments for farmers could lead to ‘big increase’ in food prices.” The newspaper explains: “An overhaul of payments for farmers designed to help Britain meet its net-zero target could cause ‘a big increase’ in food prices and even some shortages, according to an influential Commons public accounts committee. Writing in the newspaper, Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, the committee’s Conservative deputy chairman, who is “also a farmer and treasurer of the Conservatives’ 1922 committee”, states: “The current severe spike in energy price is a result of increasingly relying on imports. I do not think the public will thank us if in a few years down the road there is either a big increase in prices or worse, a shortage of food. We need to get to a point where we produce over 50% of the food that we eat in this country.”

Chinese coal traders shrug off Indonesian coal export ban

Reuters

Reuters reports that coal traders in China “are shrugging off a ban on coal exports imposed by Indonesia, saying utilities already hold hefty stockpiles with power demand set to weaken for the Lunar New Year holidays”. One trader based in Jilin province in north-eastern China is quoted saying: “If we are not expecting any (extreme) cold (weather) waves, there would be no other factors to drive up coal demand in the near term.” (Reuters says that Indonesia “is yet to reach a decision on lifting its coal export ban”. Another Reuters article says the Philippines’ energy secretary Alfonso Cusi has appealed to Indonesia to lift its coal export ban, saying the policy will be detrimental to economies heavily reliant on the fuel for power generation.) Meanwhile, China News – a Chinese state-run newswire – reports that the China National Coal Association and China Coal Transportation and Marketing Association released a “proposal” jointly, calling on their members to “safeguard the operating order of the coal market, guide market prices to return to sensible [levels]”.

Separately, People’s Daily – the mouthpiece of China’s Communist Party – runs a lengthy editorial explaining an order on energy supply from China’s president Xi Jinping last October. The 11,680-character article is titled “the energy food bowl must be held in [our] own hands”, which repeats Xi’s order word for word. The piece looks back at the People’s Republic of China’s journey to gain energy self-sufficiency, explains Xi’s order, elaborates on the importance of achieving energy self-sufficiency and lists five ways China can “hold the energy food bowl” better. (Carbon Brief analysed this particular order from Xi in China Briefing on 28 October 2021.) Moreover, the Global Times – a tabloid run by People’s Daily – reports that Chinese-owned energy projects in Kazakhstan have remained “safe” amid protests. (The demonstrations broke out following “soaring energy prices”, Al Jazeera reported previously.) The newspaper says that “the unrest will not have a big impact” on oil and gas transport from Kazakhstan to China. It adds: “Local Chinese companies said that they are prepared, and the Kazakh government will also take corresponding measures to ensure the safety.”

Elsewhere, “Working with China on climate is ‘most important element’ of the decade, NSC official says” is the headline of a report from Defense One, a website specialising in covering US defence and national security. The article writes that “the US-China relationship will be overwhelmingly ruled by competition, but the two powers must cooperate in one area: fighting climate change”. It cites Kurt Campbell, the coordinator for Indo-Pacific affairs at the National Security Council of the US. It adds that, according to Campbell, it is “critical for American officials to bring China in line with global efforts to cut emissions and end global warming”.

Bill Gates-backed fund aims to invest $15bn in clean tech

Financial Times

The Financial Times reports that a “Bill Gates-backed private-public fund is preparing to invest in clean-tech projects worth as much as $15bn in the US, EU and UK, aiming to subsidise technologies at scale to help countries reach net-zero emissions” The newspaper adds: “Breakthrough Energy Catalyst, which has raised $1.5bn in private capital from philanthropies and companies, will invest in four key areas: direct air capture, green hydrogen, aviation fuel and energy storage technologies. BEC managing director Jonah Goldman told the Financial Times that the fund would mobilise as much as $15bn, or ten times the initial investment, by using innovative financial structures and partnership agreements.”

Separately, the Financial Times also reports that Isabel Schnabel, the European Central Bank executive responsible for market operations, has said that policies to tackle climate change are likely to keep energy prices higher for longer and may force the European Central Bank to withdraw its stimulus more quickly than planned. Schnabel says that the planned transition away from fossil fuels to a greener low-carbon economy “poses measurable upside risks to our baseline projection of inflation over the medium term”. [The article is based on a speech by Schnabel in which she also states: “It would be a serious mistake if governments, faced with rising energy prices, would backtrack from their commitment to reduce emissions. Governments should also not slow down the pace of the transition or delay the phasing out of fossil fuel subsidies.”]

US: Biden calls Colorado’s most destructive wildfire ‘code red’ climate warning

Reuters

After visiting the scene of Colorado’s most destructive wildfire on record last Friday, US president Joe Biden said the event was the latest “code red” reminder of an ominously changing climate he hopes to confront with his renewable energy agenda, reports Reuters. “We can’t ignore the reality that these fires are being supercharged” by global warming, Biden said after touring a neighbourhood in the Denver-area town of Louisville. The newswire adds: “Biden also used the occasion to make a pitch for his chief legislative initiative, the Build Back Better Act, which would funnel billions of dollars to enhanced forest management, firefighting and efforts to reduce carbon emissions. The bill, opposed by Republicans, passed the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives in November. It must still clear the Senate, where it has yet to secure the needed support of all of Biden’s fellow Democrats.” The Guardian also reports Biden’s visit to Colorado, adding that his “Build Back Better bill hangs in balance as [he] takes his sixth tour of a climate disaster since taking office”. Associated Press says that Democratic senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia, who has opposed the currently worded bill, has “signalled in recent days that climate-related provisions were unlikely to be a deal-breaker, but the bill has taken a back seat to voting rights legislation and other Democratic priorities”.

Comment

Solving Britain’s high energy bill dilemma

Editorial, Financial Times

An editorial in the Financial Times says that the UK government has a “menu of potential responses” to the cost-of-living crisis, ranging from the “mostly useless but politically appealing to the more useful but challenging”. it adds: “Cutting value added tax on gas further from the current 5% rate belongs in the former category. It would be badly targeted and do little for struggling consumers. It would, however, make use of post-Brexit freedoms to diverge from eurozone VAT rates – appealing to a government looking for ways to demonstrate the benefits of the exit from the EU. Targeted help makes more sense. The government could temporarily increase the universal credit benefit for the less well-off, helping with other price pressures as well…A final option would be to increase the scope and generosity of the ‘warm homes discount’ scheme administered by the energy companies, targeting some poorer families and pensioners.” The Sunday Telegraph takes a different view. Its editorial argues that, “infuriatingly, it now seems that blaming energy companies will be part of the government’s strategy”. It continues: “The government’s energy policy is particularly dire: it remains wedded to the imbecilic price cap, it continues to discourage investment in UK gas, there is no hope for shale and nuclear is insufficiently exploited. Cheap renewables are great, and not just in theory, but the wind does not always blow and there needs to be a back-up plan.”

Writing in the Sun on Sunday, Kwasi Kwarteng, the business and energy secretary, says: “I want to reassure readers that ministers are working hard to help ease those cost-of-living pressures I know so many people are feeling. Ultimately, to shield British people from rises in global gas prices into the future, we need to move away from volatile gas and foreign imports. Unlike other countries in Europe, the UK is not dependent on Russian gas and our single largest source is within British waters. However, every country is exposed to prices set by international markets. So to better insulate ourselves from global forces, we need to generate more clean power in the UK. That means more offshore wind, solar, tidal energy, hydrogen and, crucially, our new nuclear power fleet. The more clean energy we generate in this country, the better protected we will be in the years ahead.”

In the Guardian, Torsten Bell, the chief executive of the Resolution Foundation, writes: “A £300 one-off payment to all 8.5 million low-income households would cost up to £2.5bn. A large amount, but the minimum we’re going to need to mitigate rising energy bills. And once we’re through this crisis we mustn’t forget the bigger picture – the need to tackle our failing energy sector, poorly insulated housing and reliance on fossil fuels.” In the Spectator, James Kirkup, director of the Social Market Foundation, argues that “advocates for net-zero would do well to raise their game about now, making more forcibly the argument that decarbonising home heating isn’t so much about saving the planet as about saving Britain from international gas markets”.

Meanwhile, in the Sunday Times, Ed Conway, who is Sky News’s economics and data editor, argues that “eliminating our emissions in the long run may involve more, not less, emissions in the short run”. He claims: “We will need oil and gas for decades, partly for things like carbon fibre and partly because we will need a lot of energy to make the materials out of which we’ll fabricate this new net-zero world. If we tried to do this without their thermodynamic help, we would take far longer to get there – and have to spend staggering sums to do it. This is the practical, unpalatable reality of going green.” Andrew Neil in the Daily Mail supports Lord Frost’s calls (see above) for Boris Johnson to change direction: “There is growing concern about the unquantifiable but clearly massive cost of net-zero on the Tory backbenches…The difficulties of the Tories weaning themselves off Big Taxes and the Big State should not be underestimated. But it is clear that the days of Johnson getting it all his own way are over. He will have to bow to the new rebellious mood in his party.” In the Sun on Sunday, Tony Parsons claims to speak for the “struggling workers of this country” who, he says, “are being betrayed by a government that cares more about its pious, self-harming net-zero emission goals than the Brexit promises of years ago”. Finally, in the Sunday Telegraph, Esther McVey, a Tory backbencher who has joined the climate-sceptic “net zero scrutiny” group of 19 MPs, writes: “The government should remove the cost of the green levies from energy bills. Although it is important that people understand the full cost of the rush to net-zero, removing this – at least in the short term – could cut around £170 per year from energy bills. Finally, the government needs to start sourcing the cheapest energy rather than always looking for the greenest energy. I don’t think there is anything more irritating than seeing politicians – like the Labour leader – calling on one hand for cheaper energy, whilst at the same time wooing the climate lobby and pushing for net-zero policies which are putting up energy prices. You can’t do both. We need to start having a realistic debate about the true cost and consequences of net-zero and stop pretending that you can have net-zero at a net-zero cost. We need to discuss timings and technologies too, what is realistic and what can be delivered and by when.”

Banks risk becoming new fossil fuel villains in 2022

Pilita Clark, Financial Times

Net-zero commitments from banks are making it “more visible – and troublesome – than ever before” for them to finance fossil fuels, writes associate editor and business columnist Pilita Clark in the Financial Times. She writes: “Banks may be turning on the taps for green finance but they are far from closing them for fossil fuels. The world’s 60 largest private sector banks have put more than $3.8tn into the oil, gas and coal sectors since the 2015 Paris agreement, according to NGO research.” Clark adds: “With no sign of rapid change, banks face a double difficulty in exposing their fossil financing to more scrutiny – and charges of climate villainy – without showing how they might eventually wind it back.”

An editorial in the Economist begins by noting that “[i]nvestor enthusiasm for financing the green transition is growing”. It continues: “Yet if you look more closely, you will find huge problems. If the world is to reach net-zero emissions by 2050, investment will need to more than double, to $5tn a year. And fund management is rife with ‘green-washing’…To the rescue has come the European Union, which has devised a new labelling system, or taxonomy, that sorts the economy into activities it deems environmentally sustainable.” The editorial is critical of the taxonomy, however, adding: “The plan’s flaws lie in its bureaucratic outlook. The simplistic nature of the labelling may lead to a purity test in which funds exclude assets that are dirty. In fact a key job of capital markets is to own polluting companies and manage down their emissions.” Instead, the Economist argues, the EU should make it easier to track emissions associated with investment portfolios and “use carbon pricing to alter how capital is allocated”.

Meanwhile, climate-sceptic columnist Ross Clark asks in the Daily Mail: “Why aren’t we building more low-carbon atomic energy plants instead of closing them?” He notes that all of the UK’s remaining nuclear plants are scheduled to close by 2035 and that the Hinkley Point C plant currently under construction is “so expensive”. He argues that small modular reactors can be “safer – and possibly cheaper, too”. Clark concludes: “If the government is going to have any hope of fulfilling its commitment to decarbonise electricity by 2035 it is going to have to throw its faith into this technology rather than carry on as it has done for the past two decades: building ever more wind turbines without the means to store their intermittent energy.”

Science

Soil drought can mitigate deadly heat stress thanks to a reduction of air humidity

Science Advances

Soil droughts result in “a mild reduction in heatwave lethality” despite being linked to an increase in warming, because they drive down humidity, according to new research. The authors combine “weather balloon and satellite observations, atmospheric modelling, and meta-analyses of heatwave mortality”. They find that soil heatwaves lower heat stress in humans by reducing evaporation from the surface of the soil, leading to a lower humidity level. These benefits were particularly noticeable during the Chicago 1995 and northern US 2006 and 2012 heatwaves, according to the authors. This research suggests that irrigated agriculture may intensify lethal heat stress, they add.